CCSCNE 2xxx Review Form

CCSCNE Review Form

Paper Title:
Paper Number:

Please submit your review on-line at
http://www.ccscne.org/cgi-bin/submitreviewform.cgi

1. Importance of the topic to C.S. Education:
         ___ Very important              ___ Moderately important             ___Not important

2. Interest in the Topic/Timeliness:
         ___ Great              ___ Moderate             ___Little

3. Originality of the paper:
         ___ Very original           ___ Moderately original          ___ Not original

4. Technical Quality and Accuracy of the paper:
         ___ Outstanding           ___ Good          ___ Average          ___ Fair          ___ Poor

Please justify your ratings of the Importance, Interest, Originality and Accuracy of this paper:

5. How well is this paper PRESENTED?
        Overall organization         ___ Good         ___ Average         ___ Poor
        English                             ___ Good         ___ Average         ___Poor
        Readability                       ___ Good         ___ Average         ___Poor

Please justify your ratings of the presentation of this paper:

6. My recommendation is:
         ___ Accept
         ___ Leaning to accept
         ___ Leaning to reject
         ___ Reject

Please justify your recommendation:

7. How confident are you in your abilities as a referee for this paper?
         ___ Very confident - I am an expert in this area.
         ___ Confident - I have a reasonable knowledge of this area.
         ___ Fairly confident - I have some knowledge of this area.
         ___ Not confident - I have no significant knowledge in this area.

8. If you recommend to reject, would you suggest that the paper be resubmitted as a poster?
___ Yes, I recommend resubmission as a poster.
___ No, I do not recommend resubmission as a poster.

Comments to the authors/Modifications, if conditionally accepted:

Confidential Notes (read by program chairs only):