This form can be printed and used to help prepare reviews. This year reviews will be submitted by email to the appropriate conference committee. To submit a review:
a. Copy this page into an email addressed (as appropriate) to demos@ccscne.org.
b. Make the Subject of the email: Review of proposal number xxxx (substituting the correct number).
c. Copy this page into the body of the email.
d. Fill out the page and send it.

Demo Title:

Demo Number:
Reviewer Number:

Rate the proposal according to to criteria described below. Provide comments and a justification of your rating for each of the criteria. Use the following ranking:
1 - Poor
2 - Fair
3 - Average
4 - Good
5 - Excellent

1.   Rate the level of interest of the proposal to Computer Science educators audience:_____

Comments and Justification of Rating:

2.   Rate the appropriateness for 10-minute demo format:____

Comments and Justification of Rating:

3.   Rate the potential for others to adapt the demo:____

Comments and Justification of Rating:

4.   Rate the utility of supporting material, if available:____
(Use a rating of N/A for not applicable)

Comments and Justification of Rating:

5.   Is there sufficient evidence of the author's use of the tool, activity, or assignment:____
(Use a rating of No, Maybe, or Yes)

Comments and Justification of Rating:

6.   Rate your level of familiarity with the topic:____
(Use a rating of Low, Moderate, or High)

7.   Overall recommendation:____

• Accept — provide suggestions to the presenters to improve the quality of the demo
• Accept with revisions — specify reservations in comments
• Reject
  

Comments and Suggestions:

8. Confidential comments to the committee chairs that will not be read by the authors: