CCSCNE Review Form for Panels/Tutorials/Workshops

This form can be printed and used to help prepare reviews. This year reviews will be submitted by email to the appropriate conference committee. To submit a review:
a. Copy this page into an email addressed (as appropriate) to panels@ccscne.org, workshops@ccscne.org, tutorials@ccscne.org ;
b. Make the Subject of the email: Review of proposal number xxxx (substituting the correct number);
c. Copy this page into the body of the email;
d. Fill out the page and send it.

Panel/Tutorial/Workshop Title:

Panel/Tutorial/Workshop Number:
Reviewer Number:

Rate the proposal according to to criteria described below. Provide comments and a justification of your rating for each of the criteria. Use the following ranking:
1 - Poor
2 - Fair
3 - Average
4 - Good
5 - Excellent

1.   Rate the level of interest of the proposal to an audience of computer science educators:_____

Comments and Justification of Rating:






2.   Rate the appropriateness to the panel, tutorial, or workshop format:____

Comments and Justification of Rating:






3.  Rate the evidence that the presenters will do a good job:____

Comments and Justification of Rating:






4.  Overall recommendation:

  ___ Accept - provide suggestions to the presenters to improve the quality of the presentation
  ___ Accept with revisions - must specify in comments
  ___ Reject
Comments and Suggestions:






5.   How confident are you in your abilities as a referee for this proposal?
         ___ Very confident - I am an expert in this area.
         ___ Confident - I have a reasonable knowledge of this area.
         ___ Fairly confident - I have some knowledge of this area.
         ___ Not confident - I have no significant knowledge in this area.

6. Confidential comments to the committee chairs that will not be read by the authors: